That is a really easy question. CELEBRITY! Without and hesitation or question!  DH and I love Celebrity Cruise Line.  We love that they are definitely upscale compared to the other cruise lines we have been on (RCCL and Carnival and NCL). We love their food, great! We love their cabins and we LOVE their service.  We love that they tell passengers that they can not come back to following formal nights if they are not dressed properly!  WOW a Cruise Line that Publishers Rules and Guidelines and MEANS it!!!  WE LOVE YOU CELEBRITY!!!!

Another vote for Celebrity! That's just our opinion and all cruise lines have been very good, however Celebrity is a slight notch above Holland. Of the cruise lines we've been on this is our rating from best to very good:
Celebrity
Holland America
Carnival
Princess
RCL
NCL
Our next cruise is on the Carnival Fantasy out of Mobile. It's actually two back to back five day cruises. For New Year.

good answer!

I have sailed on 2 cruise lines myself Holland America and RCCL.  Right now I like both of them about the same.  I like the Size of the Holland ships and the rooms.  I like the activities of the RCCL.

 

 

 

Robert

 

Aug 2009  -  Alaska - HAL MS Ryndam

Dec 2009  - Bahamas - RCCL Monarch of the Seas